By Peter N. Miller, Francois Louis
This publication is a venture in comparative heritage, yet alongside unique axes, one ancient and the opposite historiographical. Its objective is to constructively juxtapose the early sleek ecu and chinese language methods to ancient learn which were known as "antiquarian." As an workout in old restoration, the essays during this quantity amass new information regarding the diversity of antiquarian-type scholarship at the prior, on nature, and on peoples undertaken at both finish of the Eurasian landmass among 1500 and 1800. As a historiographical undertaking, the ebook demanding situations the received---and usually a great deal less than conceptualized---use of the time period "antiquarian" in either eu and chinese language contexts. Readers won't in simple terms examine extra concerning the variety of eu and chinese language scholarship at the past---and specifically the cloth past---but they're going to even be in a position to combine a number of the historiographical observations and corrections into new methods of conceiving of the background of old scholarship in Europe because the Renaissance, and to mirror at the effect of those ecu phrases on chinese language methods to the chinese language prior. This comparability is a two-way highway, with the eu culture clarified via wisdom of chinese language practices, and chinese language methods greater understood while positioned along the eu ones.
Read Online or Download Antiquarianism and Intellectual Life in Europe and China, 1500-1800 PDF
Best historiography books
Identify word unique name Vergangene Zukunft: Zur Semantik geschichtlicher Zeiten
Modernity within the overdue eighteenth century remodeled all domain names of ecu existence -intellectual, business, and social. no longer least affected used to be the event of time itself: ever-accelerating swap left individuals with briefer durations of time within which to assemble new reviews and adapt. during this provocative and erudite publication Reinhart Koselleck, a exotic thinker of heritage, explores the concept that of old time via posing the query: what sort of adventure is unfolded through the emergence of modernity?
Relying on a rare array of witnesses and texts from politicians, philosophers, theologians, and poets to Renaissance work and the desires of German electorate through the 3rd Reich, Koselleck indicates that, with the arrival of modernity, the earlier and the longer term grew to become 'relocated' in terms of each one other.
The provides of modernity -freedom, growth, endless human development -produced a global accelerating towards an unknown and unknowable destiny in which awaited the potential of attaining utopian success. background, Koselleck asserts, emerged during this the most important second as a brand new temporality supplying exceedingly new methods of assimilating adventure. within the current context of globalization and its ensuing crises, the trendy global once more faces a difficulty in aligning the adventure of previous and current.
To discover that every current used to be an imagined destiny will help us once more position ourselves inside a temporality geared up by way of human suggestion and humane ends up to by means of the contingencies of out of control occasions.
We be mindful the previous in a few alternative ways, a few of which we will slightly describe. yet we speak about the prior in additional particular social contexts, at domestic, at paintings, within the bar, reminiscing approximately prior event or narrating earlier occasions with particular teams of kin neighbors and associates. How humans discuss the prior is helping outline their id.
The 80 Years' battle and the institution of 2 states within the Low international locations inaugurated the e-book of various texts to help a unique Northern and Southern identification. This learn analyses city and local chorographies written either within the North and within the South within the 17th century.
- The Historiography of Landscape Research on Crete (Archaeological Studies Leiden University)
- Writing, Teaching and Researching History in the Electronic Age: Historians and Computers
- Individual Choice and the Structures of History: Alexis de Tocqueville as Historian Reappraised
- In the Past Lane: Historical Perspectives on American Culture
- Jacob Burckhardt's Social and Political Thought
- Modernity and Exclusion
Extra resources for Antiquarianism and Intellectual Life in Europe and China, 1500-1800
Marc Bloch, “Pour une histoire comparée des sociétés européennes,” Revue de Synthèse Historique 46 (1928): 15–50; “Comparaison,” Bulletin du Centre International de Synthèse 9 (supplement to RSH, 1930): 31–39. 29. Max Weber, “[Concluding Note on Method],” The Agrarian Sociology of Ancient Civilizations, trans. R. I. Frank (London: Verso, 1998), 385. 30. Among Nippel’s many works on the subject are his editions of Momigliano (Ausgewählte Schriften, Band 1: Die Alte Welt [Stuttgart: J. B. Metzler, 1998]) and Weber (Wirtschaft und Gesellschaft, Teilband 5: Die Stadt [Tübingen: Mohr (Siebeck), 1999]) and specific studies devoted to “Methodenentwicklung und Zeitbezüge im althistorischen Werk Max Webers,” Geschichte und Gesellschaft 16 (1990): 355–75; “From Agrarian History to Cross-cultural Comparisons: Weber on Greco-Roman Antiquity,” The Cambridge Companion to Weber, ed.
Nathan Sivin comments on the different professional environments of physicians in early modern China and Europe. He sees the major differences in the Chinese absence of an organized medical profession and medical university education. Yet, physicians in China shared the same classical education with all members of the scholar elite, even if civil service, for whatever reasons, was not an option for them. Medicine was thus closely connected to classical learning and physicians, though often low in political rank, were closely enmeshed in the intellectual community.
And, again, a century’s hindsight can only make us appreciate even more Stark’s unerring feel for the history of historical scholarship. Even as Carl Justi was publishing the first of his monumental three- volume biography of Winckelmann emphasizing Winckelmann and the Beautiful, Stark was publishing his own biographical essay on Winckelmann stressing Winckelmann’s roots as a “Polyhistor” who did important work on things like Merovingian diplomatica. 60 Both Herklotz and Décultot have noted the relationship between Winckelmann and Peiresc, and there is much here to go into more deeply.